a national information resource for value-added agriculture
Agricultural Marketing Resource Center

Cal/West Seeds


Woodland, California
http://www.calwestseeds.com/

Recipient of 2009 and 2006 USDA Value Added Producer grants.


Background

Cal/West Seeds is the largest member-owned U.S. cooperative devoted exclusively to the seed business. It is a marketing cooperative in an industry that is dominated by large, multinational companies. While most multinationals are focused on profit for their investors, Cal/West is focused on profits for its member growers.

The roots of Cal/West Seeds go back to 1939 when the California Ladino Clover Association was formed by 16 Ladino clover growers. Their goal was to improve their market and put production on a stable economic foundation. The “Caladino” brand was established and the name of the organization changed to the Caladino Farm Seeds as other seeds were added to the production and marketing program.

In 1950, another group of seed men formed “Calapproved” with the help of the California Farm Bureau Federation. By 1960, they had land and an office in Modesto, California. In 1969, Caladino and Calapproved merged to form Cal/West Seeds, Inc. In 1973, they purchased a 45-acre research farm in Woodland, near the location of their corporate and research offices. They also established a winter research program in Hawaii. Land was purchased in Wisconsin to establish a Midwest research center in 1975. Caladino already had expertise in the global market, having captured 85 percent of the foreign market after the Second World War. Cal/West continued to acquire germplasm and technology by purchasing breeding programs in the United States, as well as in other countries. Today, 50 percent of the cooperative's market continues to be exported seeds, primarily alfalfa and forage seeds.
 

Overview of Cal/West Seeds

Cal/West has approximately 150 actively growing members, and 450 as it relates to ownership and retains. Recently, there has been a shift in their business model. In addition to diversifying into new seeds (such as Teff) they are now concentrating on their strengths in the breeding programs and innovating new products for the market place. The Value Added Producer Grant program, which provided funding in 2006, has helped them develop new products such as Hi-Gest hybrid sudangrass that receive a higher margin so they can give their growers higher prices, keeping them in business and providing customers with value-added technologies.

They focus on proprietary products, which they wholesale and license to dealers. They develop new varieties that are desired in the market place and then license them to a private distributor who will private label the varieties. The co-op then bags the seed, labels it with the distributor’s label and ships it.
 

Overview of Producers Choice

In 2001, Producers Choice was incorporated as a wholly owned subsidiary of Cal/West. It currently has sales in excess of 15 million and is still rolling out a national distribution network for its dealers. In seven years it has grown to the $15 million level by acquiring companies that  come with talented staff and loyal customers. The ongoing strategy is to grow internally while also expanding through strategic acquisitions. It is important to their membership because with every sale that Producers Choice makes, it means they are transitioning their sourcing to Cal/West. This garners a margin at the wholesale level and also a margin at the distribution level.


Overview of Cal/West Seeds, SRL

Cal/West also has a wholly owned subsidiary in Argentina that distributes their branded products directly through dealers. Argentina is their second largest market. It is called Cal/West Seeds, SRL and it has about 3 million in sales. 
 

Business Practices

For years Cal/West has followed a traditional co-op model. They make the money and then give it back to their members, withholding primarily only the retains for capitalization. Cal/West needed capital to grow and provide a buffer to allow annual retain distributions.  Producer’s Choice earnings, which are non-member, now provide a source of capital in the form of retained earnings. This strategy allows the co-op to continue to distribute member earnings but also to build through expanded nonmember business.

With the two wholly owned subsidiaries, Cal/West has 50 percent retained earnings and 50 percent retains. They are strong financially with CoBank as their primary lender. They see their bank as a business partner. Fifty million in sales is projected for 2008/09.

The co-op uses consultants for grant preparation, information technology and advertising. They have researchers and salesmen on staff, and the rest of the employees support those functions. Research is about 5 percent of sales in direct costs, while staffing is greater than 5 percent. They are currently moving in the direction of biotechnology, and the investments and risks are greater in that arena, so they proceed with caution.

The biotech research focus is primarily on drought and stress tolerance as well as improved forage quality, with the two big areas being drought and salt. They continue to do conventional breeding, with increasing investments in biotech. They are striving to create value through innovative research while still maintaining a strong classical plant breeding program in order to be in position to introduce new technologies in high-yield, well-adapted cultivars.

The co-op’s primary purpose is to create opportunities for their growers to make a good living. They focus on generating products that are good for them to grow and help them to compete in the market place. For example, StandFast ®  alfalfa continues to grow in popularity with alfalfa hay growers and sells for a premium so it’s generating additional income for their producers.

They don’t go to a lot of trade shows; instead, they go to the International Seed Federation convention as well as numerous other trade meetings such as The American Seed Trade Association.
 

 

Challenges

The co-op’s biggest current challenge is supply. The competition with corn and wheat has accelerated in the last few years. Growing seed requires a specific skill set and knowledge, and the risks can be greater. The grower needs a premium to cover risks, and at times it can be difficult to find growers willing to deal with the uncertainties of growing seed. Typically alfalfa is a three-year crop and is contracted at a minimum established price.
 
Only a few places in the world are suited to growing small seeds commercially. In addition to California and the Pacific Northwest, Cal/West has seed production acreage in Canada, Australia and Argentina. When a drought in Australia recently hurt production, they had to turn away business due to lack of supply. California is a good seed production area, but water concerns as well as competitive pressures from high-value crops such as pistachio and almonds are making it difficult for companies such as Cal/West to put the needed seed production acreage under contract. 

The co-op structure is sometimes seen as a negative because of the failures that growers have seen. Even Cal/West board members are familiar with cooperatives that failed because they were members at the time and lost significant amounts of money. But Cal/West has a long history and they are financially strong. Their loyal growers know that their member-owned cooperative will always do what is in their best interest.
 

For More Information:
Cal/West Corporate Office, 38001 County Road 27, Woodland, California 95695, 530-666-3331

Prepared October 2008.
 

 

USDA Rural DevelopmentPartially Funded by USDA Rural Development
...and justice for all.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) prohibits discrimination in all its programs and activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, gender, religion, age, disability, political beliefs, sexual orientation, and marital or family status. (Not all prohibited bases apply to all programs.) Many materials can be made available in alternative formats for ADA clients. To file a complaint of discrimination, write USDA, Office of Civil Rights, Room 326-W, Whitten Building, 14th and Independence Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20250-9410 or call 202-720-5964.
 

Iowa State University

The names, words, symbols, and graphics representing Iowa State University are trademarks and copyrights of the university, protected by trademark and copyright laws of the U.S. and other countries.